no, his points are not valid. How is generalizing a group of people (scripters on this site) and saying they don't know shit (when the premium scripts are not open source) any different than being racist and grouping all of one culture/race and saying they are stupid? He doesn't know what my code looks like, he doesn't know my depth of knowledge in java, and he hasn't used my scripts. He is going about this the completely wrong way, not to mention he posted PRIVATE messages that are meant to be PRIVATE on a PUBLIC thread. While yes, i agree there are things I and many other could improve on, this doesn't mean he has the right to group me, or anyone else for that matter.