There 0 proof you had 3B on the account or that he recovered. We also just don't buy your story, that AFTER he recovered the account with 3B on it, you searched an old database with his name and found his password used to be "beast1" and that it suddenly works on that account that you lost "3b" on. Sorry this dispute is closed, and you are stuck with the account + no refund of the 3B. If you disagree, I'm sorry, but this looks 100% staged and we won't force any refunds.