I haven't used an ID in the past 9 years
This just happends when you cooked stuff already and u lvld up and have to interact with the range again with a cooked vriant in your inventory.
You can disable level up popup message in your settings and you are good to go until this is fixed.
EDIT:
Fixed the issue, apparently OSRS changed the way you can burn food, this was not possible if you did not complete witches house quest, now you can also burn without the quest
Khal Cooker (All in One) updated to V1.27:
- Fixed cooking chicken and meat (burning option revamp)
Live soon!
Enjoy