How long should they have served before being eligible for the rank?
- They should get it as long as they have previously been a staff and did not scam or anything along those lines. Imo, it doesn't matter how long they have served.
Do you think they should get it for doing minimal work and never being active after their departure from the team?
- I do think so. I personally do not see the pip as a reward, but an indicator. An ex-staff is an ex-staff whether they have met expectations or not. You chose them to be part of your team, so they deserve that pip when they are demoted.
Are you currently fine with this ex staff list
- Yes
If not who and why would you take them off, do not answer if you were not active when they were here. You can pm me so your answer is confidential.