Did you put Amulet of Glory (5) in your gear preset? It also buys gear that's why I always recommend not to put charged items in there (it will also use glory during quests).
In order to set a combat style all you have to do is go to gear preset tab, create a new preset or overwrite an existing one by pressing "Load Gear". The script will detect what combat style you are currently using and will display on the GUI one of FIRST (usually attack xp), SECOND (strength xp), THIRD (controlled), FOURTH (defence xp) for the 4 basic styles and FIFTH for magic which will also have a spell name such as "Water strike" on the GUI. Empty slots are marked as "null". Once you finished the preset, press "Save Preset" and then you can select this preset from the quest list window.
PS: The quick start options already have predefined gear optimized for completion at lowest level possible. The gear settings only apply to quest lists you make yourself.