Whats better?

[NovaLight]

Hello!

I'm looking into creating an FSM frame work for my scripts. I'm curious to see what the best way to do this is. So their are 2 options that I'm looking at:

Reflection by invoking methods. Passing the transition method name as a string which is in the main class.

Boolean supplier. Passing the transition boolean supplier method which is in the main class.

This is just a quick idea I've not full thought about this yet so it might be a little bit more complex.

 

[Nbacon]

Hey I love Finite State Machine. I have made one in my scheme project but for you i would recomend using koltin and do something like this.  You need some hacky code for loop backs on it self but I hope you can figure that out.

    val openbank : () -> () -> Any={
        getBank().open()
        if (getBank().isOpen){
            Closebank
        }else{
            quit
        }

    }
    val Closebank: () -> () -> Any ={
        getBank().close()

        if (!getBank().isOpen){
            openbank
        }else{
            quit
        }

    }

    var quit ={
        stop()
    }
    var c= openbank

    override fun onLoop(): Int {
        log("test")
        c= c.invoke() as () -> () -> Any


        return MethodProvider.random(1000,5000)
    }

or you can program in java with goto like code in a switch stament like 

 

  @Override
    public int onLoop() throws InterruptedException {
        switch (currentFuntion){
            case 0: stop(); break;
            case 1: open(); break;
            case 2: close(); break;
            
        }
        return 0;
    }
    
    public void open() throws InterruptedException {
        
        getBank().open();
        if (getBank().isOpen()){
            currentFuntion=2;
        }else {
            currentFuntion=0;
        }
    }
    public void close(){
        getBank().close();
        if (!getBank().isOpen()){
            currentFuntion=1;
        }else {
            currentFuntion=0;
        }
    }

I have other Ideas but there dumb

 

 

 

 

[NovaLight]

Yeah nice!

I was thinking more on the lines of a modular FSM keeping almost every action in a separate state classes.

 

Looked at your project, Looks very impressive!

[Nbacon]

9 hours ago, NovaLight said:

!

For some reason Finite and Modular dont realy mix for me. (Kmaps chace super faster when remove and adding terms)

Ps (Just a a task system)

in class you can do this just follow the koltin example

public abstract class Activity{
    public abstract void doSomething();
    public abstract boolean isDone();
    public abstract Activity next()
}

 

 

 

 

Edited August 19, 2020 by Nbacon